RSS Output
French    German    Spain    Italian    Arabic    Chinese Simplified    Russian

Letters by a modern St. Ferdinand III about cults

Gab@StFerdinandIII -

Plenty of cults exist - every cult has its 'religious dogma', its idols, its 'prophets', its 'science', its 'proof' and its intolerant liturgy of demands.  Cults everywhere:  Corona, 'The Science' or Scientism, Islam, the State, the cult of Gender Fascism, Marxism, Darwin and Evolution, Globaloneywarming, Changing Climate, Abortion...

Tempus Fugit Memento Mori - Time Flies Remember Death 

Back     Printer Friendly Version  

Bookmark and Share

Sunday, July 20, 2014

Mackay's 'Madness of Crowds' and the Tulip mania of 1636

Collective madness is certainly a well-known historical phenomenon

by StFerdIII


Tulips were imported from the Near East, originally by a wealthy aristocrat named Herwart, whose friend, one named Gesner, saw a species in Herwart's Augsburg garden, and commanded from a supplier in Constantinople, a number of the bulbs. This was 1559, a mere 30 years after the Turks had tried to take Vienna and by extension Europe; 6 years before the pivotal Turkish defeat at Malta and 12 years before the Moslem navy was smashed at Lepanto. Even in times of totalitarian threats, commerce and curiosity it appears, can soldier on.

In Mackay's opus, [review here] he has a chapter devoted to the offspring of Gesner's curiosity. And curious reading it makes too. As the Moslems busied themselves with Jihad, the good burghers of Amsterdam and the Rhineland estates preoccupied themselves with pretty flowers. The mighty tulip which is a corrupted word for 'Turban', became synonymous with wealth, sophistication and importance. The madness of crowds indeed.

Tulips make a strange store of value. They are short-lived; do not give off a perfume; and do not possess the elegance of a rose, or as Mackay says, even a sweet-pea. For some reason, the Dutch, in opposition to logic, reasonableness, common-sense and good taste, decided to make the Tulip the most valuable single asset class by 1634. It was a general insanity and the madness pervaded all ranks of society.

Mackay: “As the mania increased, prices augmented, until, in the year 1635, many persons were known to invest a fortune of 100.000 florins in the purchase of forty roots.”

In today's money that is roughly 5 million Euros. A single root of a rare Tulip species fetched no less than 2.500 florins or about 150.000 Euros. Madness what madness ?

Tulip speculation resulted in the establishment of trading depots in Amsterdam, Haarlem and elsewhere. 'Stock jobbers' jostled up the trade in tulips, selling and buying roots and bulbs on behalf of individuals and even firms. It was a form of gambling. Many grew magically rich in bulb speculation. No one wanted to be left out.

Mackay: “Every one imagined that the passion for tulips would last for ever, and that the wealthy from every part of the world would send to Holland, and pay whatever prices were asked for them.”

As money poured in from foreign lands, the prices of life's necessities increased. Houses, land, horses, carriages, and luxuries of every variety rose in value. The tulip trade became so pronounced that a separate code of laws was drawn up to manage it. An entire industry of tulip-lawyers came into existence, busy with notations, contracts, stamping and market regulation. The mania's maniacal apogee was in November 1636.

Late in 1636 brain activity returned to the Dutch. The impulses of electricity and neuron functionality reappeared. As prices skyrocketed out of control, the smarter sold and pocketed the profits, never to buy again. As this process was repeated, prices fell, never to recover. In a few short weeks it was all over.

The great scam, in which a flower cost the value of 4 large Dutch estates was extinguished. Many were ruined. The pyramid scheme of money laundering was smashed. Useless inventory abounded. Howls for government to 'do something' redounded. There was nothing for the government to do. Many rich were now quite poor. Neighbour blamed neighbour for the catastrophe. Class directed epithets against other classes. But perhaps in the end, they had only themselves to blame. Irrational greed, be in tulips or any other asset class, will always end in destruction.



Article Comments:

Related Articles:

Cult of more Debt

2/20/2016:  Real world Inflation and currency destruction.

2/6/2015:  $200 Trillion in Debt World-wide. Keynesian theology leading to a future disaster.

11/1/2014:  Cult of Central Banks. Fraud, distortions, spending, bubbles.

8/7/2014:  Nixon's sorry legacy - a systemic implosion, from real inflation and currency devaluation.

7/20/2014:  Mackay's 'Madness of Crowds' and the Tulip mania of 1636

7/17/2014:  Thomas Mackay, 'Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds” Ch. 1

7/10/2014:  Cult of bubbles, government distortions and pollyanna's - prices can only go up !

6/13/2014:  Cult of easy money - but no bubbles, issues or dislocations in finance or housing!

2/14/2014:  Central Banks, debt and future economic implosions

2/6/2014:  Real Estate is not the greatest investment

3/12/2013:  Governments just love the real estate bubble [er rational price increase...]

2/17/2013:  Modern Marxist and Statist absurdity: Only the Government creates anything.

1/18/2013:  Real debt levels are 5-10 times the size of the economy.

1/15/2013:  Bankruptcy is assured. Rhetoric to the contrary.

1/11/2013:  Waiting for Phase 2 of the Insolvency/Debt crisis.

6/5/2012:  Phase 2 of the 'Great Recession' about to begin.

12/20/2011:  REAL GDP vs. REAL Debt levels......

11/16/2011:  Real debt levels are 3-5 x the size of the economy

1/6/2010:  American debt, financial collapse and the ugly reality of Statism

3/27/2008:  Going bankrupt? Are Western states already there?