RSS Output
French    German    Spain    Italian    Arabic    Chinese Simplified    Russian

Letters by a modern St. Ferdinand III about cults

Gab@StFerdinandIII -

Plenty of cults exist - every cult has its 'religious dogma', its idols, its 'prophets', its 'science', its 'proof' and its intolerant liturgy of demands.  Cults everywhere:  Corona, 'The Science' or Scientism, Islam, the State, the cult of Gender Fascism, Marxism, Darwin and Evolution, Globaloneywarming, Changing Climate, Abortion...

Tempus Fugit Memento Mori - Time Flies Remember Death 

Back     Printer Friendly Version  

Bookmark and Share

Wednesday, April 30, 2008

Globalisation – not as 'globalised' as it would appear

More global trade would be nice.

by StFerdIII

Globalised trade and international economic integration were supposed to crush the nation state. Regional trade agreements; bi-lateral economic associations; and the IMF-World Bank 'consensus' were to eradicate state power. For the past 50 years cries and alarms have been raised about such mental distortions as 'a race to the bottom'; 'the death of the welfare state'; or 'the loss of sovereignty'. In the past 50 years the nation state has of course gotten stronger, not weaker, from globalisation. This is the saddest consquence of increased wealth creation worldwide.

The world has never been 'flat', 'borderless', or 'one'. That is a gross myth. One could argue that along most metrics the late 19th century was more open than today's world if you measure GDP invested abroad; trade as a percentage of national income; or international capital flows compared to national incomes. There is nothing that unique about the economic forces underpinning the modern development of globalisation. What is special is that the nation state has perversely grown much stronger, not weaker from this current modern brand of an age-old phenomenon.

The top 20 economies account for 70% of all trade. This simple fact means that 180 odd states are minor players or almost completely excluded from global trade flows. Even within the prosperous 20 states trade on average, accounts for 45% or less of total GDP.

The US for example has 17% of its GDP linked to exports and about 16% to imports. In compacted Europe where distances are small and borders more prevalent the totals range from 40-50% for import and exports combined. Yet the large economies of Japan, Russia, Brazil, and India have 32% or so dependent on trade. While impressive and certainly higher than 20, 50 and 100 years ago, trade and globalised money and production poses little threat to state power.

As trade increases so too do non-tariff barriers. The GATT process has reduced manufactured tariffs down to an average of 5% per product, but non-tariff barriers proliferate. Eco-regulations, 'fair' labor standards and regional sources of origin requirements, all mitigate against open trade. Some sensitive sectors such as autos; agriculture; lumber and steel are openly protected by tariffs, quotas and content requirements.

Along with rising protectionism state-owned companies are expanding, particularly in oil and gas. Governments are using these cash-cows to back huge state managed investment funds. These sovereign wealth funds from Asia and the Middle East are now invested in struggling US and European banks.

In the battle of the market versus the state, it is pretty clear that the state is in the ascendant. In the richer countries the power of the state has grown magnificently through a near doubling of most state budgets in the past 25 years and rich plethora of new tax and regulatory opportunities. In the 30 mostly rich countries of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, tax revenue as a percentage of the local economy was higher in 2005 then ever before – on average about 40% of GDP.

Across the developed and more prosperous world, demands by the old, the sick, the 'poor', and those on the margins of society, or in regions which are less wealthy than 'core' areas; are demanding more. Equality, 'justice' and communal values are now the norms for the nation state. Individualism, capitalism, unrestrained supply and demand interactions are now regarded as loathsome in most states. This is largely due to the state's power to control, regulate or monopolise key sectors of information, education, and the media.

Only in few countries is there any form of competition in the media, education, or the public space. The internet has allowed many non-state actors to spread and discuss state independent viewpoints, but in many countries even this vehicle is being crushed by 'Human rights commissions' which target certain 'offenders' in order to aid certain state approved 'victims'. The state is very good at trying to control free speech and debate.

Far from being powerless in the face of global economic and trade forces, the state has become far more powerful. Markets can only operate within a state. The state ensures security, contracts, rights, laws, regulations, borders and well known processes. Markets cannot operate in an anarchic world. States have seized the opportunities afforded by trade to do 3 things:

1.increase national wealth and relevancy
2.erect more programs and regulations and
3.engage in more agreements and compacts in order to limit and define and thereby control cross border transactions.

The real perversity is this: the more 'global' we become, the stronger the state becomes. This is a fact which should give everyone pause. Freedom of economic exchange should lead to greater individual freedoms and reduced state interference. The fact that we have the opposite should be very unsettling to anyone who promotes freedom and civilisation. State power is anathema to what makes civilisation's great.

Article Comments:

Related Articles:

Trade&Globalisation vs Marxism

5/5/2012:  Changing Geo-Economic reality

1/12/2012:  Offshoring, Inshoring and the Government-Union nexus

8/9/2011:  Rosenberg right on the state of affairs.

12/31/2010:  An immoderate economic stimulus plan.

12/6/2010:  Free Trade – not as free as we think.

7/11/2010:  Yield Curves are forecasting another Recession or worse.

6/27/2010:  G20 – expensive posturing. A $1 billion waste of time.

12/22/2009:  The stock market crash of 1929 – caused by liquidity and government.

9/29/2009:  The current market run up is a fantasy-world.

9/25/2009:  The Consumer is NOT 70% of the economy.

7/28/2009:  Governments caused this mess - don't reward them.

7/19/2009:  Once you start to socialise some markets why bother stopping ?

6/3/2009:  Governments caused this 'crisis'.

3/16/2009:  Herbert Meyer: The Cure for Poverty is Capitalism

2/19/2009:  Why there will be a 'second' recession

11/28/2008:  The Auto-Union working elite! Annointed workers united.

11/25/2008:  Governments caused the current economic mess.

7/22/2008:  Falling Bear Markets are sending some important messages.

6/25/2008:  Why We Outsource in Technology

4/30/2008:  Globalisation – not as 'globalised' as it would appear

4/26/2008:  Food prices: governmental morons and the eco-cult causing food price and supply problems.

3/20/2008:  Markets work – even in downturns

3/6/2008:  Destroying the US$ is not good policy

3/2/2008:  Free Trade is simply the only solution to help the poor.

2/8/2008:  The consumer is NOT 70% of the total economy.

11/7/2007:  Why $100 per barrel oil, won't kill the economy

9/4/2007:  Anglo-Saxon market dynamics simply work

9/2/2007:  Forms of Capitalism and their benefits

8/30/2007:  Innovation and Wealth Equals Inequality

5/28/2007:  Technology, Technology, Technology

5/24/2007:  Income ‘inequality’ and Trade – even smart people can be dumb

5/23/2007:  Forget Laissez-Faire we have ‘Lazy–Fair’!

5/9/2007:  Mommy, there are scary Trade monsters in my bedroom!

5/8/2007:  Trade benefits all of society

3/9/2007:  End subsidies and protectionism

3/5/2007:  The benefits of tax competition and offshore banking

3/4/2007:  Markets limit unaccountable government power.

3/1/2007:  The failure of Unions and Big Government

2/10/2007:  New debates, on old ideas, using old rhetoric

1/4/2007:  Innovation and the market

11/20/2006:  Lessons from the past: lower tax levels increase wealth and jobs

9/22/2006:  Oil pricing - absurd marxian analysis on the rise and fall of prices

5/17/2006:  Tax cuts are mandatory to create wealth for all

1/17/2006:  Manly countries lower taxes and increase wealth

9/30/2005:  Tax Cuts Increase Revenues, Jobs and decrease poverty

9/18/2005:  Human Progress: Technology, Capital and freedom

7/11/2005:  Note to Bono and Rich Do-Gooders - Please shut the hell up

2/25/2005:  Globalization

2/25/2005:  Tax and Trade

2/25/2005:  Productivity

2/25/2005:  Regionalism

2/25/2005:  Environment

2/25/2005:  Currency

1/5/2005:  Canada and USA need a Flat Tax