RSS Output
French    German    Spain    Italian    Arabic    Chinese Simplified    Russian

Letters by a modern St. Ferdinand III about cults

Gab@StFerdinandIII -

Plenty of cults exist - every cult has its 'religious dogma', its idols, its 'prophets', its 'science', its 'proof' and its intolerant liturgy of demands.  Cults everywhere:  Corona, 'The Science' or Scientism, Islam, the State, the cult of Gender Fascism, Marxism, Darwin and Evolution, Globaloneywarming, Changing Climate, Abortion...

Tempus Fugit Memento Mori - Time Flies Remember Death 

Back     Printer Friendly Version  

Bookmark and Share

Tuesday, March 24, 2009

A contrarian view on Obama's bank bailout and spending plans

The stock markets might like it – but who wouldn't like the government giving them a few hundred billion ?

by StFerdIII

The stock markets rallied in one of their biggest gains in history, on the news that the US government under the benign leadership of Prophet Obamed had developed a plan to eradicate toxic US bank debts. It is not surprising that the markets rallied on the news – which industry would not gladly receive $100 billion or more in government bailouts and handouts ? What is more surprising is the lack of analysis by the 'market' or the mainstream media on the Prophet's plan. When scrutinized it becomes clear that this plan will do very little to alleviate US bank woes. It might actually make them worse.

The plan by government to 'save' US banks is pretty straightforward. Banks have bad debt premised on bad mortgage loans and securities. The government will work with the private sector to buy off this debt. Once relieved of this debt the banks will start lending. Once they start lending the economy will expand. As money flows into the economy, firms and people will take on more debt and buy more products. Once they occurs, we will be in happy-land.

Plan in skeleton:
-Governments will use $100 billion and probably a lot more, to buy bad bank assets in conjunction with the private sector

-Governments will own about 75% of the toxic portfolio and the private sector the rest. The actual government and taxpayer guarantee will be given by government agencies such as the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation and Treasury. The private sector will only be adding 6% to the purchase of the assets:

“FDIC would guarantee 72 cents in funding for an asset purchased for 84 cents on the dollar. The feds and private investors would each put up six cents in capital. If the asset rises in value over time, the taxpayer and investors share the upside. If it falls further, then the taxpayers would absorb by far the biggest chunk of the losses. Better hope the recovery really is, as the White House says, just around the corner.” [WSJ]

-The initial $100 billion might grow depending on the extent of the toxic assets which need to be bought

-The idea is that if the value of the asests grows, the taxpayers and private sector will make profits.

It could be worse – but there are a number of major issues with this program that make it in various degrees, too small; too restrictive and too interventionist:

1.The total amount of US Bank bad assets is estimated to be $1 to $ 3 Trillion in total.
2.Many analysts see housing prices declining by another 20-30% which would mean that the toxic bank debt will only get worse.
3.If banks follow this plan they might actually have to disclose the real value of their diminished assets – resulting in yet another sell off of bank stocks and a public panic over their solvency.
4.The original $100 Billion would need to be increased 10 fold to deal with what is perhaps the real level of bad assets inside US banks.
5.This would mean another $1 Trillion US tax payer bailout to buy off bad mortgage based securities.

Other problems with the plan include the obvious objections:

1.If house prices go down the taxpayer funded bailout will lose money
2.If the government is involved most savvy investors will not participate – why would anyone trust a government which is ferociously advancing the role and scope of the state, with their private money?
3.As time wears on the government can change the rules and wipe out the owners of this debt.
4.At what point will this program be wound down and how ?
5.Why are bad banks and bad managers being rewarded and saved ?

It would be better simply to mark down the assets to market, write them off and then restructure the banks. If some banks go into bankruptcy, than the law will protect the firm, the deposits and its workers, as the bank goes through a restructuring. It would punish wrong doers; inept managers and greedy banks. It would send a clear message to the banking market and its executives – when you screw up, when you defraud, when you engage in debt manipulation, you will be punished.

In summary this banking package will not save the banking system. It will only be a costly failure which will only delay the inevitable restructuring of the banking system, banks and the executives who manipulated the markets and who should not be receiving anything but congressional investigations and jail terms.

Article Comments:

Related Articles:

USA - cult of big Gov't

11/13/2014:  Central Bank cult, free money, no interest rates....Keynesian nirvana

9/8/2014:  Stockman and the cult of central banking

3/26/2014:  The cult of government and micro-managing the economy

1/29/2014:  Globaloneywarming and Economic illiteracy

1/28/2014:  Bernanke and the next great implosion[s]

4/13/2013:  Economist-Quacks ''Assume a Perfect World'

12/5/2011:  Statism. The inexorable rise of big nanny government since 1947.

9/9/2011:  Obamism and the failure of the Keynes model

8/21/2011:  The 2011 Recession.

8/8/2011:  Only the media and the politicians are surprised by the financial meltdown.

5/12/2011:  Old age transfers and bankruptcy.

5/10/2011:  GDP calculations are wrong

4/23/2011:  Inflation and debt.

4/18/2011:  Why does America still have a Triple A credit rating?

4/15/2011:  Cut government in half or see your taxes double.

4/14/2011:  US debt and the Republicrats.

1/10/2011:  Unions, the surest path to failure and bankruptcy.

11/5/2010:  Central Bank madness. Another bubble is guaranteed.

10/29/2010:  Economist Kotlikoff: 'US is bankrupt.' We know.

10/25/2010:  Regulations and government killing local jobs. Choquant!

2/17/2010:  Government stimulus programs only stimulate government not jobs

2/5/2010:  Economic Lies – US GDP ‘Growth’ [Hardy Har Har]

1/14/2010:  Government created stock fraud.

1/10/2010:  Politicized Central Banks do not control inflation.

10/6/2009:  The Empire's decline is forecasted in its dollar.

8/25/2009:  Governments caused this 'crisis'.

8/22/2009:  The Chairman's failure - Government 'Stimulus' never works.

7/16/2009:  Obama Health Care – a very sick idea.

4/9/2009:  The Real Estate bubble of 1815-1819

3/24/2009:  A contrarian view on Obama's bank bailout and spending plans

3/13/2009:  Economists Fail Prophet Obamed.

2/10/2009:  Stimulating nothing but fear, big government and Obama's left wing addictions

11/29/2008:  The Black Jesus and the old, 'New Deal ' to 'create' 2.5 million jobs!

11/23/2008:  Keynesian economics is a failure.

5/2/2008:  Recession evidence is now finally here and it will be nasty.

4/13/2008:  Who are the 'poor' exactly?

1/3/2008:  We need tax cuts not massive interest rate cuts.

11/13/2007:  US Income mobility is strong

11/9/2007:  The Empire's declining dollar.

10/31/2007:  America vs. Europe

10/14/2007:  The Mommy-State cult

9/10/2007:  Tales of market woe and pain: Blame the Fed

8/17/2007:  Conrad Black Deserved to Fall

8/24/2006:  Supply side economics works

5/12/2006:  Illegal immigration is a net drain on society

8/17/2005:  US Protectionism – Steel Tariffs, the Byrd Amendment and now Lumber

7/15/2005:  US Revenues are up, deficit is down, but no media reports

5/25/2005:  US Savings and Net Assets Highest in the World

5/25/2005:  Bush’s Fiscal Policy is Wrong

4/25/2005:  The US Economy – rising expectations

3/25/2005:  Why Trade Deficits Don't Matter

1/4/2005:  Why the US$ will go up

11/15/2004:  Jobs, Jobs, Jobs