RSS Output
French    German    Spain    Italian    Arabic    Chinese Simplified    Russian

Letters by a modern St. Ferdinand III about cults

Plenty of cults exist - every cult has its 'religious dogma', its idols, its 'prophets', its 'science', its 'proof' and its intolerant liturgy of demands.  Cults everywhere:  Islam, the State, the cult of Gay and Queer, Marxism, Darwin and Evolution, 'Science', Globaloneywarming, Changing Climate, Abortion....a nice variety for the human-hater, amoral, anti-rationalist to choose from.  It is so much fun mocking them isn't it ?

Tempus Fugit Memento Mori - Time Flies Remember Death 

Back     Printer Friendly Version  

Bookmark and Share

Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Quackery about 'why the earth rotates', not much science here

Not much progress in the last 650 years....

by StFerdIII

 Christian scholastics from the 13th and 14th centuries sound more scientific than our modern big-brains on many topics, one being the question; why does the earth rotate at 1000 miles per hour ? Have you ever heard a convincing reason ? The medieval explanation for the earth's rotation, premised on debates which began sometime in the early 14th century at the University of Paris and elsewhere, attempted to use higher mathematics, logic, and naturalist observations to explain if, how, and why the earth rotates. Today it appears that 'science' has largely given up on this tradition of trying to understand how and why the earth rotates, falling back as usual, on worn-out 'evolutionary' themes and memes. No math, no science. From NASA, the institute non-pareil of naturalist theological 'reasoning' makes the following claim about the earth's rotation:

Why do Earth and the other planets rotate at all? It will help to understand how our solar system formed. Almost five billion years ago, our solar system had its beginnings as a vast cloud of dust and gas. The cloud began to collapse, flattening into a giant disk that rotated faster and faster, just as an ice skater spins faster as she brings her arms in. The Sun formed at the center, and the swirling gas and dust in the rest of the spinning disk clumped together to produce the planets, moons, asteroids, and comets. The reason so many objects orbit the Sun in nearly the same plane (called the ecliptic) and in the same direction is that they all formed from this same disk.

While the planets were forming, there was not much peace in our solar system. Clumps of matter of all sizes often collided, and either stuck together or side-swiped each other, knocking off pieces and sending each other spinning. Sometimes the gravity of big objects would capture smaller ones in orbit. This could be one way the planets acquired their moons.” NASA

This is not science, but science-fiction. There are as many questions embedded in the above summary as there are sentences of opacity and innuendo. From NASA the modern explanation is as follows:

-The Big Bang occurred and the chaos formed vast clouds of dust and gas.

-This cloud magically 'collapsed' [don't all outward rushing chaos-driven particles in a vacuum just suddenly stop and collapse ?]; forming a fast-spinning flat disk.

-Planets somehow formed from this chaos and driven by the rotating 'flat disk' began an endless orbit around the Sun or ecliptical.

-Collisons were common and moons were formed from such cosmic traffic accidents.

-Spinning spheres magically rotate for 5 billion years.....what happened to the law of entropy?

Nothing in NASA's summary tells a thing about the origins of the rotation of the earth and why after 4 or 5 billion years it still spins. Cause and effect? Motive force? Nothing. NASA does helpfully add that Mars crashed into Earth and likely increased the original rotational speed. Thanks NASA.

Many other 'scientific' theories exist but they sound like a used-car sales pitch from Stephen Hawking.

In 1350 Catholic Priest Jean Buridan most likely influenced by many others, wrote on the projectile motion, falling bodies, and the rotation of the earth. Without Buridan and the Scholastics there is likely no Copernicus, Kepler, Galileo or Newton. Buridan tore apart the static, immobile earth of Aristotle and tried to prove and measure why and how the earth rotated. Buridan explained celestial motion using impetus or force theory, something Aristotle had rejected:

"...one who wishes to jump a long distance drops back a way in order to run faster, so that by running he might acquire an impetus which would carry him a longer distance in the jump. Whence the person so running and jumping does not feel the air moving him, but rather feels the air in front strongly resisting him."

This impetus theory is still with us today. According to Buridan and restated in Newtonian physics, celestial bodies did not suffer resistance in the celestial vacuum, which would repress or distort that impetus. Buridan anticipates Newton's First Law of Motion. He does not however, [nor has anyone else], uncovered the 'original' impetus. What caused the effect of spinning in the first place ?

Nicholas of Oresme followed Buridan, taught in Paris and died as bishop of Lisieux in 1382. Oresme investigated the daily rotation of the earth. The common objection to the idea that the earth moved or rotated, was premised on Aristotelian 'laws' which stated that if you dropped 2 stones from a tower, the first dropped did not fall behind the second. Hence it appears that the earth is immobile as stated by Aristotle. Oresme's answer to this objection was simply to use Buridan's theories. The earth's rotation was imparted to bodies and was kept undiminished by them. This is exactly the same theme taken up by Copernicus.

According to historian Copleston:

"He discovered, for example, that the distance traveled by a body moving with a uniformly increasing velocity is equal to the distance traveled in the same time by a body moving with a uniform velocity equal to the velocity attained by the first body in the middle instant of its course. Moreover, in order to express these and similar successive variations of intensity in a manner which would facilitate understanding and comparison, Nicholas conceived the idea of representing them by rectangular co-ordinates, that is to say, by means of graphs."

The above was a highly significant advance in science and the physics of motion. Without it there is no Galileo or Copernicus.

Thomas Kuhn a noted historian of science wrote:

"Jean Buridan and Nicole Oresme, the fourteenth-century scholastics who brought the impetus theory to its most perfect formulations, are the first men known to have seen in oscillatory motions any part of what Galileo saw there."

In effect the NASA-mainstream science explanation as to why the earth rotates, is Buridan's and Oresme's from c. 1350. The impetus described by these two Christians is now attributed to the Big Bang, a theory that is far from proven and is riven with problems and issues. In fact the Big Bang is so unproven that calling it scientific is pointless. In other words, as far as 'why does the earth rotate' little progress beyond story-telling, has been made in 650 years. Source


Article Comments:

Related Articles:

Cult of Darwin

10/16/2016:  Evolution's absurdity is revealed when you look at DNA

10/8/2016:  4-D Genomic software code disproves Evolution

9/28/2016:  Cyanobacteria and disproving Evolution. Nano-Technology does not 'evolve' by chaos.

9/15/2016:  Evolution's non-science; abiogenesis and proteins

9/10/2016:  Evolution's ignorance of science, bio-chemistry and math is profoundly disturbing

9/5/2016:  Bananas and Chimps are the same as humans! So says the 'science' [fiction].

8/29/2016:  Evolution's Fantasy world. A pagan religion, not a science.

8/21/2016:  Evolution offends the basic laws of Physics and Thermodynamics

8/12/2016:  Evolution's magic friend mutations does not support its theology

8/5/2016:  Evolution-denying the decomposition of DNA with magic hand-waving

7/28/2016:  Great French Mathematician Schützenberger, knew Darwinism was a false idol

7/20/2016:  Human embryology disproves the Cut of Evolution

7/4/2016:  Evolution cannot explain the formation of amino acids, DNA or RNA

6/17/2016:  The Nitrogen cycle and the processes of Life are not explained by the cult of Evolution

6/9/2016:  Dr. D Russell Humphreys Phd Physics on why he left Darwin's cult and did some real science

5/25/2016:  Evolution, no positive mutations can be identified, so that makes it all about science....

5/8/2016:  Not one single experiment or observation proves Evolution, abiogenesis, or life from chance

5/8/2016:  Evolution fails basic math and biochemistry

5/1/2016:  Dragons, cultures and reality

4/21/2016:  The Holy Church of Atheism and its dogmatic miracles

4/9/2016:  Cult of Evolution; complex molecules do not last millions of years

4/2/2016:  No beneficial genetic mutations turning algae into the Alchemist are known. None

3/28/2016:  Evolutionists admit single cell is too complicated to develop from 'nothing'.

3/19/2016:  Jerry Bergman and the nexus of Darwinist and Marxist evil

3/14/2016:  Evolution: an epic fail in probability and common sense

3/9/2016:  Feathers disprove the cult of Evolution [as do 1 million other facts]

3/2/2016:  Eugenics, Nazi theology and Evolution

2/19/2016:  Bubonic plague and deleterious mutations which deform, destroy, eradicate

2/10/2016:  Apes to Men myths, bio-chemically impossible.

1/14/2016:  Cell complexity and software is not supported by Darwinism

1/7/2016:  Iron preserves soft tissue for 75 million years ? LOL

1/3/2016:  Design cannot arise by randomness

12/9/2015:  DNA is software code and software code cannot self-create, repair, instruct, design.....

11/22/2015:  Nobel Prize for DNA self-repair. Evolution offends basic bio-chemical science.

11/16/2015:  Software and cellular repair - both offend the cult of Darwin's simplistic view of life.

11/15/2015:  Water: Darwinian theology cannot explain the core miracle of life.

11/7/2015:  Genetic Entropy & The Mystery of the Genome, by John C. Sanford,

10/30/2015:  The bio-chemically ignorant believe in Evolution

10/17/2015:  Evolution's illogic and lack of ontology. No science here. Meet the platypus.

10/11/2015:  So you are a rational-scientist-enlightenment-realist ?

10/3/2015:  Darwin's cult is mathematically impossible. It also offends basic science.

9/26/2015:  Everett Koop and the bleedingly obvious. The cult of Darwin is not based on science.

9/21/2015:  Homo Naledi and the missing science, and the missing proof, in the missing link claim

8/29/2015:  Benjamin Wiker: 'Moral Darwinism', the case against the cult of pond scum to people

8/15/2015:  Darwin's cult is long dead. Time to move on.

8/4/2015:  Jerry Bergman, Freud's atheism built upon the failed theology of Darwinism

8/3/2015:  Jerry Bergman and Freudian theology derived from Darwinism

7/30/2015:  Everything proves Darwinism! A typical cult belief.

7/24/2015:  Darwinism is anti-science.

5/28/2015:  Darwin's cult is ignorant of the obvious: 'In the Beginning Was Information', by Werner Gitt

5/23/2015:  DNA mutations mean that the Human species must be 20.000 years or less in age

5/20/2015:  From E Coli to Yeast and Humans ?

5/10/2015:  Dr. J. F. Ashton, 'Evolution Impossible'.

5/2/2015:  Darwin's magic friends and going from grass to humans!

4/27/2015:  Complex information systems arose by random chance! No science here !

4/8/2015:  Nothing Created Everything: The Scientific Impossibility of Atheistic Evolution by Ray Comfort

3/27/2015:  Hooved animals to Whales ! Oh yeah, this is 'science'

3/26/2015:  Evolution propaganda is anti-science. It retards scientific inquiry.

3/20/2015:  Stephen Meyer, Signature in the Cell. The Magic Fairyland of Darwinism.

2/27/2015:  Nazi Darwinism. Borman and the Nazi hatred of the Church.

2/20/2015:  Insulin by itself disproves Evolution

2/13/2015:  Evolution is a Fraud and Non-Science.

1/19/2015:  Ribosome's and the cell's factories - all by random chance and luck!

1/7/2015:  Benjamin Wiker, '10 Books that Screwed up the World' - Darwin's 'Descent of Man'

12/23/2014:  The Darwin Myth, The Life and Lies of Charles Darwin, by B. Wiker Phd

12/12/2014:  Darwin's Dissenters. Surely the cult will punish them.

12/10/2014:  The unscientific cult of the Phd. Quackery and letters do not make science.

12/4/2014:  Hitler the Atheist Evolutionist and Darwin cult member.

11/17/2014:  Cult of Darwin: There is no tree of life and mutations degrade

11/6/2014:  The Brain dead cult of Darwin - basic math mocks this cult

10/26/2014:  Bio-chemistry makes a mockery of Evolution

9/27/2014:  'Evolution's Achilles Heels' and the cult of Darwin

9/22/2014:  Evolution's Achilles Heels - and there is plenty of them

9/16/2014:  Apes did not 'evolve' into humans. Genes and our software make this obvious.

9/3/2014:  The fossil record does not support Evolution. Neither does reality.

9/1/2014:  Evolution - no evidence, no fossil proof, no bio-chemical proof....

8/25/2014:  Stove and the abject miserable philosophy of Darwinian cant and dogma

8/20/2014:  Evolution Science Fiction: The Tree of Life, and the ignorance of DNA

8/6/2014:  The Evolution Conspiracy, Exposing Life's Inexplicable Origins & The Cult of Darwin, Lisa Shiel

7/31/2014:  Darwinism-the greatest joke er hoax on earth. Particles to Professors you say?

7/24/2014:  Photosynthesis and the Human Eye laugh at Darwinism and order from chaos

7/18/2014:  DNA disproves evolution - software code is not written by chance

7/15/2014:  Tax money funding Darwin's cult - a state attack on science and Deism

7/8/2014:  Bergman, 'Hitler and the Nazi Darwinian Worldview'

6/19/2014:  Why I left the cult of Evolution - it is not science, it is fantasy

6/13/2014:  Evolution is not science, DNA and Anatomy make a mockery of Ape to Human theorizing

6/5/2014:  Darwinian dogma at the root of the Nazi leadership belief system

6/2/2014:  'Strange Glory', by Charles Marsh - a book about the Nazis vs the Church

5/31/2014:  Hitler and the Nazis hated the Catholic Church

5/31/2014:  The Barbarism of Evolution

5/30/2014:  Bergman, Darwinism And The Nazi Race Holocaust

5/22/2014:  Conway: 'The Nazi persecution of the Churches' - What else would good Darwinists do?

5/20/2014:  The Nazis appealed to 'science' to sell their Fascism

5/6/2014:  Darwin was not a scientist: 'The Dark side of Charles Darwin', by Jerry Bergman

5/5/2014:  The Dark Side of Charles Darwin, by Jerry Bergman PhD

4/30/2014:  The Dawkins Proof, by R. Barns

4/6/2014:  From Darwin to Hitler, Prof. Richard Weikart [3], Darwin and Racism to Communalism

4/4/2014:  Co2 was much higher in times past, today's level is 'below normal' so why the fuss ?

3/29/2014:  10 Reasons why Evolution is not science

3/28/2014:  List of Evolution's better known frauds. Criminality is now Science!

3/25/2014:  Sagan, Tyson and the Science Fiction of Evolution and the Universe

3/22/2014:  Age of the Solar System - we don't really know the age of anything

3/19/2014:  Quackery about 'why the earth rotates', not much science here

3/18/2014:  Big Bang, Big Fraud, Big Atheism

3/15/2014:  From Darwin to Hitler, Prof. Richard Weikart [2]

3/7/2014:  Book Review: 'From Darwin to Hitler', by Prof. Richard Weikart

2/10/2014:  Geneticist says the obvious; Evolution is absurd

1/21/2014:  Proofs of God's Existence by Richard Wurmbrand

1/6/2014:  What Your Atheist Professor Doesn't Know (But Should) by Stephen Williams

12/19/2013:  Evolution is for the dead of brain: 'Vanishing Proofs of Evolution', by Thomas Heinz

12/12/2013:  Ferrell: Evolution Handbook, part 4 – Science fiction as 'science'

12/3/2013:  Evolution handbook, by Vance Ferrell part 3

11/26/2013:  Evolution handbook, by Vance Ferrell part 2 The Big Bust

11/22/2013:  'Evolution Handbook', by Vance Ferrell

11/13/2013:  A Moslem scientist's view of the cult of Darwin

10/29/2013:  Why the Materialist Neo-Darwinian Conception of Nature Is Almost Certainly False, Thomas Nagel

10/23/2013:  What Darwin Got Wrong by Jerry Fodor, Massimo Piattelli-Palmarini

10/17/2013:  The cult and illiteracy of Scientism. Quacks as experts.

10/10/2013:  Evolution: Fact or Fiction? - The Secret Truth Darwinists Don't Want You to Know by Randy Ruggles

10/2/2013:  The Devil's Delusion, by David Berlinski

9/26/2013:  Evolution is Stupid! By John Verderame

9/19/2013:  Icons of Evolution: Science or Myth? by Jonathan Wells

9/11/2013:  The Mysterious Epigenome, by Thomas E. Woodward, James P. Gills

8/30/2013:  Darwin's Doubt: The Explosive Origin of Animal Life by Stephen Meyer

8/22/2013:  Darwinism, beyond faith into fantasy.

8/14/2013:  The Church of the Holy Evolution and Sacred Heart of Random Chance

8/8/2013:  Cell's Design: How Chemistry Reveals the Creator's Artistry by Fazal Rana

7/25/2013:  Answering the New Atheism: Dismantling Dawkins' Case Against God by Benjamin Wiker, Scott Hahn

7/19/2013:  Evolution is science ? So too are little green men from planet X.

7/9/2013:  Michael Denton, 'Evolution: A theory in crisis' – No kidding.

6/12/2013:  Book Review: Darwin's Black Box, The Biochemical Challenge to Evolution, M. J. Behe

5/29/2013:  “Darwin on Trial” by Phillip E. Johnson

5/4/2013:  The cult and theology of Darwinian stage theory. Junk and Bunk as 'science'.

2/13/2013:  Immanuel Velikovsky, 'Earth in Upheaval', 1955 reprinted 2009, 263 pages